Secret Societies: The Founding Fathers
The Founding Fathers of Secret Societies Exposed
"Rhodes scholarships favoured American students, with two allocated for each of the fifty states and territories, but only sixty places for the entire British Empire. The 'best talents' from the 'best families' in the US were to be nurtured at Oxford, spiritual home of the secret elite, and imbued with an appreciation of 'Englishness' and 'retention of the unity of the Empire.'"
~~ Quote from the incisive essay on secret societies "New World Order: The Founding Fathers"
Dear friends,

A number of years ago I awakened from an unusual dream in which the name Caroll Quigley featured so prominently that I awoke with it clearly in my mind. It was a name I'd never heard before, yet the imprint was so strong that I decided to do an Internet search.
To my great surprise, it turned out Quigley was a revered professor who was considered a mentor by Bill Clinton and many other prominent figures. His specialty was secret societies and their influence on our world. He had been given privileged access to secret files of the power elite that few have ever seen.
Quigley's scholarly research has inspired many who have delved into the hidden history of our world, including the authors of the incisive essay below on secret societies and the global elite, "New World Order: The Founding Fathers." The authors base much of their research on the work of Prof. Quigley and provide dozens of footnotes to verify their story. If you don't have a lot of time, read just the sections highlighted in bold below to at least get the big picture. You won't regret it.
Carroll Quigley - Public Authority and the State in the Western Tradition
With best wishes for a transformed world,
Fred Burks for PEERS and WantToKnow.info
White House interpreter and whistleblower
Note: Read an excellent 10-page summary of Prof. Quigley's masterpiece Tragedy and Hope.
New World Order: The Founding Fathers
By Gerry Docherty and Jim Macgregor
First published in July 2013
Rich and powerful elites have long dreamed of world control. The ambitious Romans, Attila the Hun, great Muslim leaders of Medieval Spain, the Mughals of India all exercised immense influence over different parts of the globe in set periods of recognised ascendancy.
Sometimes tribal, sometimes national, sometimes religious, often dynastic, their success defined epochs, but was never effectively global until the twentieth century. At that point, with the future of the British Empire under threat from other aspiring nations, in particular Germany, a momentous decision was taken by a group of powerful and determined men. Their decision was that direct action had to be taken to assert their control, and that of the British race, over the entire civilised world. It has grown from that tiny select cabal into a monster that may already be beyond control.
"One wintry afternoon in February 1891, three men were engaged in earnest conversation in London. From that conversation were to flow consequences of the greatest importance for the British Empire and to the world as a whole."
So begins Professor Carroll Quigley's book The Anglo American Establishment. It may read like a John Le Carre thriller, but this was no spy fiction. The three staunch British Imperialists who met in London that day, Cecil Rhodes, William Stead and Lord Esher, were soon joined by Lords Rothschild, Salisbury, Rosebery and Milner, men whose financial, political, and administrative powers set them apart.
Some of these names may not be familiar to you, but that is a mark of the absolute success of this group. From the outset they insisted on secrecy, operated in secret and ensured that their influence was airbrushed from history. They believed that white men of Anglo-Saxon descent rightly sat at the top of the racial hierarchy and they fully understood the impending threat from a burgeoning Germany whose modern, expanding economy had begun to challenge British hegemony on the world stage.
The above named elites drew up a plan for a secret society that aimed to renew the bond between Great Britain and the United States [1] and bring all habitable portions of the world under their influence and control. The U.S. had grown rapidly in self-esteem, wealth and opportunity since the declaration of independence in 1776, but Anglo-American connections remained strong and would embroil her in the long-term plan for one world government. The meeting in 1891 was, in effect, the birth of the New World Order cabal.
Great financiers frequently used their fortunes to influence questions of peace and war and control politics for profit. Cecil Rhodes was different. He was determined to use his vast fortune not simply to generate ever-increasing profit, but to realise his dream, a dream he shared with his co-conspirators. Rhodes turned the profit objective on its head and sought to amass great wealth into his secret society in order to achieve political ends, to buy governments and politicians, buy public opinion and the means to influence it. [2]
He intended that his wealth should be used to grasp control of the world, secretly. Secrecy was the cornerstone. No one outside the favoured few knew of the group's existence. They have since been referred to obliquely in speeches and books as "The Money Power", "The Hidden Power" or "the men behind the curtain". All of these labels are pertinent, but we have called them, collectively, the secret elite.
Carroll Quigley revealed that secret elite influence on education was chiefly visible at the exclusive English private schools, Eton and Harrow, and at Oxford University, especially All Souls and Balliol Colleges. [3] This immensely rich and powerful group was given intellectual approval and inspiration by the philosophy of John Ruskin, professor of fine arts at Oxford. He spoke to the Oxford undergraduates as members of the privileged ruling class, telling them that they possessed a magnificent tradition of education, rule of law and freedom. He championed all that was finest in the public service ethic, duty and self-discipline, and believed that English ruling class tradition should be spread to the masses across the empire. [4]
But behind such well-serving words lay a philosophy strongly opposed to the emancipation of woman, had no time for democracy and supported the "just" war. [5] Ruskin advocated that control of the state should be placed in the hands of a small ruling class. Social order was to be built upon the authority of superiors, imposing upon their inferiors an absolute, unquestioning obedience. He was repelled by the notion of levelling between the classes and by the disintegration of the "rightful" authority of the ruling class. [6]
Ruskin's philosophy was music to the ears of the elitists. It gave their lust for global power the blessing of academic approval. What they did, they would claim, was not for them, but for mankind. They would rise to power on the spurious justification that the world would consequently be a better place for humanity.
Inspired by Ruskin, Cecil Rhodes and his accomplices created the secret society with an inner core of trusted associates called "The Society of the Elect", who unquestionably knew that they were members of an exclusive cabal devoted to taking and holding power on a world-wide basis. [7]
A second outer ring, larger and quite fluid in its membership, was named "The Association of Helpers". At this level members might not have known that they were an integral part of, or inadvertently being used by, a secret society. Many on the outer edges of the group, idealists and honest individuals, may never have been aware that the real decisions were made by a ruthless clique about whom they had no knowledge. [8]
The man who exposed the secret society, Carroll Quigley (1910 – 1977), was the highly esteemed professor of history at the School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University, and a lecturer at Princeton and Harvard. He revealed that the organisation was able to "conceal its existence quite successfully, and many of its most influential members... are unknown even to close students of British History". [9]
Quigley's greatest contribution to our understanding of modern history came with his books, The Anglo-American Establishment and Tragedy and Hope, A History of the World in Our Time. The former was written in 1949 but only released after his death. His disclosures placed him in such potential danger from an Establishment backlash that it was never published in his lifetime. In a 1974 radio broadcast, Quigley warned the interviewer, Rudy Maxa of the Washington Post, "You better be discreet. You have to protect my future as well as your own." [10]
Quigley had received assistance of a "personal nature" from individuals close to what he called the "Group", but "for obvious reasons" he could not reveal their names. [11] He made it clear that evidence about them was not hard to find "if you know where to look," [12] and it has to be asked why generations of historians have failed to pursue his trail.
Though sworn to secrecy, Professor Quigley revealed in the radio interview that Sir Alfred Zimmern, the British historian and political scientist, had confirmed the names of the main protagonists within the secret society. Without a shadow of doubt, Zimmern himself was a close associate of those at the centre of real power in Britain. He knew most of the key figures personally and was himself a member of the inner core of the secret society for twelve years between 1910 and 1922. [13]
The enigma of Professor Quigley's work lies in his statement that while the secret cabal had brought many of the things he held dear close to disaster, he generally agreed with its goals and aims. [14] Were these merely words of self-preservation? Be mindful of his warning to Rudy Maxa as late as 1974. Quigley clearly felt that these revelations placed him in danger.
Unknown persons removed his major work, Tragedy and Hope, from the bookstore shelves in America, and it was withdrawn from sale without any justification soon after its release. The book's original plates were unaccountably destroyed by Quigley's publisher, the Macmillan Company, who, for the next six years "lied, lied, lied" to him and deliberately misled him into believing that it would be reprinted. [15] Why? What pressures obliged a major publishing house to take such extreme action? Quigley stated categorically that powerful people had suppressed the book because it exposed matters that they did not want known. The reader has to understand that we are discussing individuals whose power, influence and control were unrivalled.
From the very start, each of the initial conspirators brought valuable qualities and connections to the society. Cecil Rhodes was Prime Minister of the Cape Colony and master and commander of a vast area of Southern Africa which some were already beginning to call Rhodesia. His wealth had been underwritten by brutal native suppression [16] and the global mining interests of the House of Rothschild, [17] to whom he was answerable. William Stead was the most prominent journalist of his day and a voice to which ordinary people listened.
Lord Esher represented the interests of the monarchy from Queen Victoria's final years, through the exuberant excesses of King Edward VII, to the more sedate but pliable King George V. His influence was immense because he operated between monarchs, the aristocracy and leading political figures. He chaired important secret committees, was responsible for appointments to the Cabinet, the senior ranks of the diplomatic corps and voiced strong personal opinion on top army posts. [18] Esher exerted a power behind the throne far in excess of his constitutional position. His role of powerbroker on behalf of the secret elite was without equal. Indeed Professor Quigley dubbed him, "the greatest wire puller of the period." [19]
Another name that pervaded all that was powerful and influential during this period was that of the Rothschild dynasty, and Quigley placed Lord Nathaniel (Natty) Rothschild within the very core of the secret organization. [20] Rothschild was all-powerful in British and world banking and virtually untouchable.
"The House of Rothschild was immensely more powerful than any financial empire that had ever preceded it. It commanded vast wealth. It was international. It was independent. Royal governments were nervous of it because they could not control it. Popular movements hated it because it was not answerable to the people. Constitutionalists resented it because its influence was exercised behind the scenes – secretly." [21]
Taken together, the principal players, Rhodes, Stead, Esher, Rothschild and Milner represented a new force that was emerging inside British politics, but powerful old traditional aristocratic families that had long dominated Westminster, often in cahoots with the reigning monarch, were also deeply involved, and none more so than the Cecil family. Robert Arthur Talbot Gascoyne-Cecil, the patriarchal 3rd Marquis of Salisbury, ruled the Conservative Party at the latter end of the nineteenth century. He served as prime minister three times for a total of fourteen years, between 1885 and 1902 (longer than anyone else in recent history). When he retired as prime minister in July 1902, he handed over the reins of government to his sister's son, Arthur Balfour.
Lord Salisbury had four siblings, five sons and three daughters who were all linked and interlinked by marriage to individuals in the upper echelons of the English ruling class. Important government positions were given to relations, friends and wealthy supporters who proved their gratitude by ensuring that his views became policy in government, civil service and diplomatic circles. This extended 'Cecil-Bloc' was intricately linked to "The Society of the Elect" and secret elite ambitions throughout the first half of the twentieth century. [22]
Another member of the inner core, Lord Alfred Milner, offers cause for greater scrutiny because he has been virtually airbrushed from the history of the period. Alfred Milner was a self-made man and remarkably successful civil servant who became a key figure within the secret elite and absolutely powerful within the ranks of these privileged individuals. He and Rhodes had been contemporaries at Oxford University, and were inextricably connected through events in South Africa. Rhodes recognised in him the kind of steel that was required to pursue the dream of world domination, "I support Milner absolutely without reserve. If he says peace, I say peace; if he says war, I say war. Whatever happens, I say ditto to Milner." [23] Milner grew in time to be the most able of them all, to enjoy the privilege of patronage and power, a man to whom others turned for leadership and direction.
When governor general and high commissioner of South Africa, Milner deliberately caused the Boer War in order to grab the Transvaal's gold and use the economic resources of South Africa to extend and perpetuate secret elite control. He had the grace to confess in a letter to Lord Roberts, Commander in Chief in South Africa, that
"I precipitated the crisis, which was inevitable, before it was too late. It is not very agreeable, and in many eyes, not very creditable piece of business to have been largely instrumental in bringing about a big war." [24]
This was no immodest boast. Alfred Milner's matter-of-fact explanation displayed the cold objectivity that drove the secret elite cause. War was unfortunate, but necessary. It had to be. They were not afraid of war.
The secret elite's war against the Dutch settlers began in October 1899 and ended with the signing of the Treaty of Vereeniging on 31 May 1902. The Boer Republics were annexed to the British Empire. The Transvaal's gold was finally in the hands of the secret elite at a cost of some 70,000 dead on the battlefields, plus 32,000 dead in British concentration camps, including more than 20,000 children of Dutch descent.
Some thirty thousand Boer farms were burned to the ground, livestock slaughtered, and the women and children put in British concentration camps. In the camps, the families of men fighting for the Boer army were punished by being put on half the already meagre rations with no meat whatsoever. [25] W. T. Stead, former member of the inner core of the secret elite who had resigned in disgust over the Boer War, was overcome by the evidence presented to him. He wrote,
"Every one of these children who died as a result of the halving of their rations, thereby exerting pressure onto their family still on the battle-field, was purposefully murdered. The system of half rations stands exposed, stark and unashamedly as a cold-blooded deed of state policy employed with the purpose of ensuring the surrender of men whom we were not able to defeat on the field." [26]
20,000 children dying in British concentration camps were of little consequence to Milner. He was so driven that he ignored the weight of opposition ranged against him. He warned his friend, Richard Haldane: "If we are to build up anything in South Africa, we must disregard, and absolutely disregard, the screamers." [27] It takes a very strong man to disregard the screamers, to ignore moral indignation, to put the cause before humanitarian concerns. Some frontline politicians find it all but impossible to stand against a torrent of public outrage, but those behind the curtain in the secret corridors of power can easily ignore 'sentimentality'.
Milner's period of stewardship in South Africa had a very important consequence. He administered the defeated Transvaal and Orange Free State as occupied territories, and recruited into the upper layers of his civil service a band of young men from well-to-do, upper-class, frequently titled families who became known as "Milner's Kindergarten." [28] They replaced the government and administration of the Boer republics, and worked prodigiously to rebuild the broken country. [29] The Kindergarten comprised new blood; young educated men – mostly Oxford graduates, with a deep sense of duty, loyalty to the Empire and capable of populating the next generation of the secret society. [30] In the period 1909-1913 the Kindergarten set up semi-secret groups, known as Round Table Groups, in the United States and the chief British dependencies.To continue reading this article clicked on this link: Secret Societies: The Founding FathersThe Founding Fathers of Secret Societies Exposed
The global elite: power and influence
How business and secret societies shape global politics
Highlighting the role of business (capitalist elites) and the powerful social groups shapes important worldwide developments, and even globalization was caused by concrete political decisions. Globalization is said to be produced by forces of Western modernity, particularly capitalism, rationalism, and technology. The global elite in neo-liberal perspectives generally prioritizes economic material prosperity over security. This 'economism' is a more desirable goal than a country's military status, political prestige, or cultural self-determination. Obviously, they represent a powerful social group (class) that repeatedly promotes its own cause.
For example, transnational business agendas have been shaping all post-Cold War U.S. grand strategies of 'Open Door Imperialism' regardless of the actual administration in office. Or, corporate (industrial) interests have managed to influence EU governance and discourse and played an important role in completing the internal market. Neoliberals emphasize the global interconnectedness (complex interdependence) of almost all states, societies, and markets and believe that nation-states are increasingly challenged by various transnational processes. So, neoliberal theory stresses the role of international relations and multilateral interactions, flows of information, people, and goods across and beyond nation-states.
The neoliberal transnational actors include corporations, activist groups (NGOs), churches, criminal organizations, or governmental networks of various domestic officials (bureaucrats, judges), and their respective counterparts abroad. Also, politicians, economists, right-wing journalists, and businessmen, especially those affiliated with the financial sector (even European central bankers can constitute an epistemic community). The transnational capitalist class, CEOs, and companies among Western and primarily Anglo-American or English-speaking bourgeoisie, and transnational class networking, is best demonstrated by freemasonry as a high society cosmopolitan web of capitalists and other privileged segments across different countries and regions.
Politicians and epistemic communities (a network of professionals with recognized knowledge and skill in a particular issue-area) manage many increasingly complex problems, set the agendas, and influence subsequent decision-making.
Super-ultra-rich people play key roles in every integral global decision. The Rothschild, Morgan, Rockefeller, Goldman Sachs, Lehman, Kuhn Loeb, Walton, Arnault, and others are families that are influencing the world. And it’s not about the richness. The world’s wealthiest individuals, the new technological billionaires like Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, and Bill Gates, are active on a global scale and will likely be the most powerful for a long time.
The elite group—a self-conscious 'transnational managerial class' situated at the top of the emerging global socioeconomic hierarchy—was organizing around the Trilateral Commission, IMF, World Bank, and OECD, and they made a certain 'American business culture' hegemonic all over the world. Members of the transnational managerial class were executives of multinational corporations and high staff of international agencies, and also those who manage the international-oriented sectors within countries (like globalizing bureaucrats—the finance ministry officials). Transnational capital shapes worldwide production and society, and due to globalization, capital has gained greater power over labor. Finally, the financial capital of Western economies possesses an advantage over productive capital and the real economy as a whole.
Interconnectedness between major global companies and elite policy groups—planning groups like the Trilateral Commission, Bilderberg Group, and World Economic Forum—facilitates mediation and consensus among various segments. They link together political actors and opinion-makers with big business. Regular private gatherings at Bilderberg or Davos play an important integrative function for the global corporate policy network, and they are unique meeting platforms for hundreds of corporate directors and public officials. Neoliberalism has succeeded in channeling wealth from subordinate classes to dominant ones and from poorer to richer countries. Indeed, all major institutions are said to serve the interests of the global ruling elite.
The Trilateral Commission unites leading American, European, and Japanese businessmen. Some neo-Marxists claim that the Trilateral Commission is almost behind everything and that it purportedly dismantled the former welfare states and pushed the projects of the EU, APEC, and NAFTA. The Trilateral Commission misused the World Bank development loans to redirect resources from poorer post-communist countries to various Western overpaid experts and companies. In another context, it was said that global elites are interested in maintaining poverty in the Third World. The editorial member in the journal Capital and Class made an insinuation that the recession and unemployment are often wittingly brought about by governments to decompose labor into a more readily exploitable source of labor power.
In order to secure its unchallenged hegemony, the transnational elite does not hesitate to wage 'global wars.' Regardless of the target, the wars were always staged by the transnational elites since they really decided and because the interventions furthered their hidden agendas. The Gulf Wars, the global campaign against terrorism, and the military attacks on Serbia are all examples of wars launched by the transnational elite against the perceived challenges to the New World Order. Among other means, the elite is using 'drug culture' to push the oppressed into passivity.
Capitalist plot? Or really true?
The Trilateral Commission is a non-governmental international organization of private citizens founded in 1973, principally by American banker David Rockefeller, to confront the challenges posed by the growing interdependence of the United States and its principal allies and aimed at fostering closer cooperation between Japan, Western Europe, and North America. Founders: David Rockefeller, Zbigniew Brzezinski, Jimmy Carter... The Trilateral Commission's headquarters are in Tokyo (Asia Pacific Group), Paris (European Group), and Washington, D.C. (North American Group). The Trilateral Commission represents influential commercial and political interests, and there are 400 members, including leading figures in politics, business, finance, media, and academia. Meetings are held annually.
Conspiracy theories have surrounded secret societies for centuries, such as The Knights Templar, The Freemasons, The Bavarian Illuminati, Skull and Bones, Bilderberg, etc.
The Knights Templar were warriors pledged to live a life of chastity, poverty, and obedience and were dedicated to protecting Christian pilgrims to the Holy Land during the Crusades. Headquartered at Temple Mount in Jerusalem, the Knights Templar owned the island of Cyprus, a fleet of ships, a bank, and lent money to kings. After the fall of Acre, the Knights Templar withdrew to Paris, where they focused on their banking endeavors. Conspiracy theorists spread rumors that the Knights Templar guard artifacts like the Holy Grail and the Shroud of Turin. The Cross of Lorraine, the Knights Templar symbol, was a symbol of the French resistance to Nazi rule.
Freemasons—America is the creation of the world’s oldest secret society. Thirteen men who signed the first U.S. Constitution were Masons (George Washington, James Monroe, Benjamin Franklin, John Hancock, Paul Revere, etc.). Freemasons led the revolution and framed the Declaration of Independence. But Freemasonry, as we know it today, was founded in 1717, when four London lodges formed England’s first Grand Lodge. Freemasonry quickly spread across Europe and the American colonies. Freemasonry members are encouraged to believe in a Supreme Being or Grand Architect of the Universe. The symbol of the Freemasons is the square and the compasses. Some have interpreted the 'G' as representative of God—the Grand Architect of the Universe. 'The Eye of Providence'—the All-Seeing Eye—appears as a masonic symbol on the dollar bill. Freemasons exist today.
The public image of Freemasons has been greatly influenced by the high-profile charity work of the Shriners (an American masonic society headquartered in Tampa). It is a fraternity based on fun, fellowship, and masonic principles of brotherly love, relief, and truth. Aspiring Freemasons must ask to join, as summed up in the recruiting slogan: "All you have to do is ask." The Catholic Church condemned the Freemasons because of their secret rituals and masonic temples. Famous Freemasons include Mozart, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Winston Churchill, and John Wayne.
The Illuminati was founded by Professor Adam Weishaupt in Bavaria, chafing at the power of the conservative Catholic Church. The Bavarian monarchy organized religion in favor of a new form of illumination. Inspired by the spread of Enlightenment across Europe, Karl Theodor of Bavaria issued an edict making membership in the Illuminati punishable by death. The group has been linked to everything, from the French Revolution to the assassination of JFK. The Illuminati served as inspiration for Dan Brown's Angels and Demons, and Foucault's Pendulum by Umberto Eco.
The Order of Skull and Bones is a secret society founded at Yale University, Connecticut, and their building is known as 'The Tomb'. A list of Bonesmen includes presidents and modern-day power brokers—Bush father and son, John Kerry, members of the CIA, Wall Street bankers, chief justices, Fortune 500 elites, etc. The controversial 1986 exposé America's Secret Establishment claimed that Skull and Bones was out to create a 'new world order'. The year 322 B.C. in their symbol represents when Alexander the Great died.
Other secret elite societies include the Knights of Malta, Ku Klux Klan, Opus Dei, The United Ancient Order of Druids, Rosicrucians, Rotary Club, and others. The World Economic Forum (WEF) is an independent international organization for public-private cooperation. The Forum engages the foremost political, business, and other leaders of society to shape global, regional, and industry agendas and to improve the state of the world. They say that in their mission of improving the state of the world lies the belief in the power of human ingenuity, entrepreneurship, innovation, and cooperation, and that they strive for a better world.
The WEF has no power to make decisions, but it may have considerable ability to influence political and business policy decision-making. The Euro-Atlantic Bilderberg Club is not strictly a secret society. It was formed to create a dialogue among political leaders, academics, and industry executives and to ensure cooperation and harmonious relationships between Europe and North America. The Bilderberg Group unites elites from Western Europe, North America, Canada, Turkey, and other countries. The first Bilderberg meeting was in 1954 and was held at the hotel Bilderberg in the Netherlands. This club gathers once a year over one hundred of the most powerful people on the planet, including presidents, prime ministers, banking and corporate magnates, generals, members of the intelligence services, representatives of the media, and academia (e.g., Prince Charles, Bill Clinton, Angela Merkel, Bill Gates, Tony Blair, etc.).
Most politicians who participated in Bilderberg conferences became prime ministers, presidents, or top representatives of international organizations like the EU, NATO, and the IMF. Journalists are barred from reporting on it. The 2018 Bilderberg meeting was particularly significant because, for the first time in history, the Cardinal and Secretary of Vatican State, Pietro Parolin, was present. He had previously participated in the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland. One line of interpretation of this precedent sees the arrival of the Vatican Secretary of State as a direct indication of the Vatican's placement at the head of the Mondialists.
The realization of a planned geopolitical strategic prearrangement of the planet and the implementation of Agenda 21 and Agenda 2030, the introduction
of completely scientific and technological control of the population (quantum computers and 5G technology), the replacement of human work by artificial intelligence, and accordingly the imposition of an ideological matrix that will drum madly in the media space that man is outmoded and cannot withstand the competition of technology—are all seen as part of this agenda. The victory of recognizing China as a superpower and its New Silk Road is considered by Daniel Estulin (author of the book Bilderberg Club) as a positive sign that opens a space for the survival of humanity, exhausted by the rule of crazed globalists who belong to the circle of the financial banking elite. These clubs bring together people who wish to create lasting changes in the world according to their measures and exclusively according to their needs (profit) and selfish beliefs.
Many believe some covert but influential organization is responsible for globally impactful circumstances or events. And the truth is that people conspire — they gather in small groups and work together to take control. Such meetings have been going on since the beginning of our species. But when the actions of secret societies become sinister and harmful to others, then perhaps it’s time for the populace to wake up.




No comments:
Post a Comment